Alternatives for Eviction

Eviction can be a messy process for both landlords and tenants. Thankfully, it isn’t always a necessary conclusion. There are other options that can either accomplish the same goal as eviction or that can get rid of the need for one at all.

General Eviction Process

It is important for every landlord or property manager to have a decent understanding of the legal eviction process and its steps, even if they have never had to go through it before. The eviction process includes terminating the lease, court orders, official notices, appropriate communication, and adherence to state laws. These details are important to know so that you do not unintentionally either go through with an illegal eviction or, if you end up in court, do something to damage your eviction claim.

Keep in mind that, while it is typically legal to go through with winter evictions, it is illegal in most states to shut off utilities while the tenants are still in the unit. This is especially true in states that often get temperatures below 15 degrees.

How to Tell When to Evict

There are a variety of reasons for you to evict a tenant, whether out of necessity or desire. These reasons can include, but are not limited to:

  • Habitually late rent payments or total failure to pay rent
  • Lease violation
  • Disrupting other tenants
  • Holdover
  • Using the property for illegal purposes
  • Damage to the property

Depending on the offense, there are many alternatives to eviction that you can use rather than going through the eviction process. However, if eviction still turns out to be the only option, then be sure to look at your state and local laws so you can proceed with a legal eviction.

Possible Eviction Alternatives

Try Online Rent Payments

If a tenant is having issues with paying rent, then you can send them a “late rent” notice. Hopefully, this will spur them to pay their rent and the problem solves itself, but if not, online payments have proven to be very effective at eliminating late rent or no payments. Consider setting up online rent payments to ensure your renter pays on time each month.

However, if extenuating circumstances have occurred and the tenant is temporarily unable to pay the rent for the month, then you can create a payment plan for them. Only make a payment plan if you trust this tenant and if they have a good history with you. Payment plans are effective if a trusted tenant is experiencing financial hardship. You can give them an extended deadline or establish a weekly payment arrangement while they get through their current situation. 

Seek Mediation

If the issue with your tenant is an argument or other form of conflict, mediation is a popular option. A mediator is brought in as an independent third party to make a decision after all involved parties have stated their cases. Having documentation of your issues will help to build your case ahead of time and to make the mediator’s job easier. The decision of the mediator is not legally binding, which leaves you and your tenant to either accept it or not. Many states also provide mediation boards to handle property management disputes like this.

Give Notice on a Month-to-Month Agreement

Depending on your local and state laws, there is always the chance that you might be able to get rid of a problematic tenant by simply not renewing their lease agreement. If you are having issues with your tenant and are unhappy with them, then they most likely have a problem with you as well and wouldn’t want to renew the lease anyway. This can be a good option for parting on, at the very least, unargumentative terms. If you have a month-to-month rental agreement, you can also give them a written 30 days (depending on your state’s notice laws) notice to vacate the property. This sounds like eviction but is slightly different because it gives your current tenants time to find a new home and time for you to find a more suitable tenant for your property and keeps you from facing an expensive eviction process.

Offer “Cash for Keys”

A simple, but effective, solution is to provide your tenant with a monetary incentive to leave on their own. The “cash for keys” method provides tenants with a chance to receive some cash if they move out by a day you both agree on. This method lets you avoid the eviction process and the fees that come with it. The most important part of this method is to do a documented move-out inspection so you can deduct your tenant’s deposit and get proof of the transaction.

These alternatives are all great to keep in mind so you can avoid the potentially long and costly eviction process. But the best way to protect your real estate income from a negative tenant situation is always going to be proactive before the tenants even sign the lease.