single-family vs multfamily investing

Trying to decide what your first rental property investment should be? We will break down the pros and cons of investing in single-family rental properties vs. multifamily rental properties, from the cost of entry to the kinds of tenants you’re likely to encounter. 


If you’re planning to invest in a rental property, you may be curious about what kind of property you should consider investing in. Multifamily properties are quite different from single-family properties in a variety of ways, meaning that the process of owning and managing these properties might create different experiences for landlords and investors alike. This article will break down a few of the pros and cons of investing in single-family rental properties and multifamily rental properties, so you can make the right decision about your property investments. 

Remember that one property isn’t the end-all, be-all of your investment career, so try not to put too much pressure on yourself. You need a good investment, not a perfect one. With that in mind, here are the pros and cons of investing in both single-family properties and multifamily properties. 

Pros and Cons of Single-Family Rentals

Pros and Cons of Single-Family Rentals

Single-family rentals have numerous benefits, but also some drawbacks that should be noted. These benefits include, but are not limited to: 

  • Lower cost of entry than the price of purchasing a multifamily rental unit, making them easier to afford, including with financing options such as mortgages or house hacking
  • Less responsibility for utilities than you would have if you owned a multifamily property, as you have the option to expect tenants to pay their utility bills rather than to have them included in the rent like they often are with multifamily properties
  • Higher per-unit rent prices, as renters are typically willing to spend more to rent a single-family home than they would to rent an apartment
  • Larger pool of buyers should you choose to sell in the future

However, single-family properties aren’t perfect investments, and you may encounter issues as an investor. The drawbacks of single-family investments include: 

  • Higher per-unit cost since you’re buying each property separately rather than a group of units on one property 
  • Less control over each property, since landscaping, the exterior of the property, and other similar maintenance tasks aren’t under your purview unless you make a point of hiring maintenance people for them
  • Less room for scaling since you can’t put multiple units on one property like you would be able to with a multifamily property 
Pros and Cons of Multifamily Rentals

Pros and Cons of Multifamily Rentals

Multifamily rentals can be quite different from single-family homes. Of course, this carries with it a difference in the benefits and drawbacks of investing in them. These multifamily properties are great for many reasons, but not for everyone. Benefits of investing in a multifamily rental property include: 

  • Safer investment than most other options, as multifamily housing is often the preference of renters during times of economic struggle
  • Vacancy causes less difficulty, as it is highly unlikely that all of your units would sit vacant for an extended period of time, meaning you’re not entirely out of luck with rent like you would be if your one multifamily property was vacant
  • More rental income from multiple units than you would receive from a singular unit

However, these benefits also come with some disadvantages. Cons of investing in a multifamily property include: 

  • Higher initial investment than what you would typically need to put into a single-family home
  • Maintenance is more expensive, and maintaining the exterior of the units and the property they sit on is your responsibility; you may also face additional requirements for accessibility or zoning laws that don’t impact single-family homes.
  • Tenant conflict is more likely because living so close to one another makes it more likely for your tenants to have issues with one another, which you may need to mediate and resolve
Should I Invest in Single-Family or Multifamily Rentals?

Should I Invest in Single-Family or Multifamily Rentals?

The interesting thing about this question is that there isn’t a right answer. Single-family rentals and multifamily rentals both have some amazing benefits and some drawbacks that might ward off certain investors. Fortunately, you’re not obligated to choose one option or the other. Many landlords and property investors, especially those with big portfolios, own both single-family and multifamily rental properties. 

Learn more: Inside My Real Estate Portfolio: From Single-Family Homes to Multi-Family Investments 

Investing in a Single-Family vs. Multifamily Rental

Final Thoughts 

Investing is an exciting process and comes with a lot to think about, especially when it comes to choosing your first few investments. Determining whether a single-family home or a multifamily property suits your needs better is one of these decisions, but you can take comfort in knowing that it’s not one that locks you into any one style of investment. Ultimately, neither option is better or worse than the other, so it’s important to consider both options and develop an investment strategy that works for you.